According to the nothing to hide argument, there is no threat to privacy unless the government uncovers unlawful activity, in which case a person has no legitimate justification to claim that it remain private. But when confronted with the plurality of privacy problems implicated by government data collection and use beyond surveillance and disclosure, the nothingtohide argument, in the end, has nothing to say. Choice a book like privacy scholar daniel soloves nothing to hide is sorely needed. Choice a book like privacy scholar daniel solove s nothing to hide is sorely needed. Solove recognizes that enhanced judicial scrutiny and a predicate requirement come with a cost the cost associated with greater barriers to government intervention. Note if the content not found, you must refresh this page manually. Ive got nothing to hide electronic surveillance of communications, privacy and the power of arguments dipl. John dean quotes professor solove in his recent article and the pdf link doesnt seem to work except on the above webpage. They might have nothing to hide their present governments observations and laws, but it takes little effort to find points in history where the same people might have held opinions or taken actions contrary to the laws of the time. Similarly, i have never seen an if youve got nothing to hide, youve got nothing to fear. Thus, if an individual engages only in legal activity, she has nothing to worry about. In popular discourse, the nothing to hide arguments superficial incantations can readily be refuted. The false tradeoff between privacy and security yale university press 2011 translations into korean and japanese understanding privacy harvard university press. Daniel solove offers a unique, challenging account of how to think better about and of privacy.
Request pdf ive got nothing to hide and other misunderstandings of privacy. The false tradeoff between privacy and security, chapter 1, yale university press, 2011. Nevertheless, the nothingtohide argument is far from vanquished. In this essay, i will explore the nothing to hide argument and its variants in more depth. Daniel soloves critique of the nothing to hide argument mirror, 2007 blog post, ssrn paper, which is so often brought up. Variations of nothing to hide arguments frequently appear in blogs, letters to the editor, television news interviews, and other forums. Nothing to hide is a super fantastic, easy to read book about the argument between whether safetysecurity or privacy should be held in higher regard within society. Variations of nothingtohide arguments frequently appear in blogs, letters to the editor, television news interviews, and other forums. The parts are how we should assess and balance the values of.
Solove is john marshall harlan research professor of law, george washington university law school. May 23, 2006 one of the most common attitudes of those unconcerned about government surveillance or privacy invasions is ive got nothing to hide. Is there a good response to the nothing to hide argument. Only if youre doing something wrong should you worry. Soloves new book, nothing to hide, shatters that myth. Why privacy matters even if you have nothing to hide 2011.
Ive got nothing to hide and other misunderstandings of privacy by. Here are a few short excerpts from my nothing to hide essay. The false tradeoff between privacy and security, chapter 1, yale university press, 2011, gwu law school public law research paper no. One of the most common attitudes of those unconcerned about government surveillance or privacy invasions is ive got nothing to hide. Ive got nothing to hide and other misunderstandings of. Nothing to hide available for download and read online in other formats. Professor solove is the organizer, along with paul schwartz of the. Nevertheless, the nothing to hide argument is far from vanquished. Solove wrote when engaged directly, the nothingtohide argument can ensnare, for it forces the debate to focus on its narrow understanding of privacy.
Ive got nothing to hide publish your masters thesis. Solove doesnt directly address data permanence or longterm storage as a harm though it might obliquely fall under his data processing category. Aug 05, 2014 nothing to hide adherents have a temporal problem. Daniel solove s critique of the nothing to hide argument mirror, 2007 blog post, ssrn paper, which is so often brought up in discussions about privacy and civil rights. He is well known for his academic work on privacy and for popular books on how privacy relates with information technology solove wrote three books about privacy that had been published from 2004 to 2008. This book reaffirms the value of privacy, shows how endangered it is, and proposes real. But, as the crimeespionage distinction analysis makes clear, this is a price solove is willing to pay to more closely protect privacy values. I was talking the issue over one day with a few colleagues in my field, and we all agreed that thus far, those emphasizing the value of privacy had not been able to articulate an answer to the nothing to hide argument that would really register. But when confronted with the plurality of privacy problems implicated by government data collection and use beyond surveillance and disclosure, the nothing to hide argument, in the end, has. The nothing to hide argument and its variants are quite prevalent, and thus are worth addressing.
Grappling with the nothing to hide argument is important, as the argument reflects the sentiments of a wide percentage of the population. Grappling with the nothing to hide argument is important, because the argument reflects the sentiments of a wide percentage of the population. Thus, if an individual engages only in legal activity, she. May 28, 20 finally, solove reiterates the difficulty with the nothing to hide argument because most privacy problems lack dead bodies solove 768, meaning that people tend to focus on issues that viscerally and physically affect them while data mining, and privacy intrusion is something intangible and abstract. Solove also claims convincingly that even though this book is focused on american law, the modern debate over privacy or the lack thereof is universal. There will always be a need for citizens to demand accountability and oversight of government surveillance, or else we will gradually slide into a more dystopian world. Solove curriculum vitae 2 publications books breached. Among other works, he authored the future of reputation. They are based on mistaken views about what it means to protect privacy and the costs and benefits of doing so. In this essay, solove critiques the nothing to hide argument and exposes its faulty underpinnings. Sascha klein essay law philosophy, history and sociology of law publish your bachelors or masters thesis, dissertation, term paper or essay. Although the nth privacy view characterized by solove 17 raises many new and important research questions, there is scarce empirical research on this consumer segment. Solove takes apart the arguments and assumptions animating current surveillance efforts, and in a storytelling style, helps us appreciate the full range of their costs and benefits.
Solove s new book, nothing to hide, shatters that myth. This book part is brought to you for free and open access by the faculty scholarship at scholarly commons. In addition to attacking the nothingto hide argument, solove. When the government gathers or analyzes personal information, many people say theyre not worried. Jul, 2007 the nothing to hide argument and its variants are quite prevalent, and thus are worth addressing. But saying that you dont need or want privacy because you have nothing to hide is to assume that no one should have, or could have to hide anything including their immigration status, unemployment history, financial history, and health records.
In this essay, solove critiques the nothing to hide argument and exposes its. It is a 25 page pdf file but as this fisa debate is happening, we are going to be seeing a lot of the ive got nothing to hide argument and this paper should do well to refute that. It means giving up your privacy on demand to any one in authority. The false tradeoff between privacy and security yale university press, 2011. Why privacy matters even if you have nothing to hide the. Nothing to hide provides a thoughtprovoking, accessible introduction to privacy and security law.
Nothing to hide makes a powerful and compelling case for reaching a better balance between privacy and security and reveals why doing so is essential to protect our freedom and democracy. Solove says the claim ive got nothing to hide argument, which is so often mentioned in discussions concerning the governments gathering and examination of our personal information. Click download or read online button to get nothing to hide book now. Variations of nothingtohide arguments frequently appear in blogs, letters to the. But when confronted with the plurality of privacy problems implicated by government data collection and use beyond surveillance and disclosure, the nothing to hide argument, in the end, has nothing to say. Privacy and the nothing to hide argument schneier on security.
Download nothing to hide or read nothing to hide online books in pdf, epub and mobi format. No scholar in america is more committed to demystifying the right to privacy. Why privacy matters even if you have nothing to hide dan. Nothing to hide pdf download full pdf read book page. My anecdotal understanding is that almost all security cameras in the uk are privately owned and generally passively monitored e. Here are a few short excerpts from my nothingtohide essay. Others argue that we must sacrifice privacy for security. The nothingtohide argument my essays 10th anniversary. The book examines the laws, government agencies and social concerns of the argument and how the argument plays out in each context.
The book is peppered with literary, historical, and legal references and examples. But when confronted with the plurality of privacy problems implicated by government data collection and use beyond surveillance and disclosure, the nothingtohide argument, in the end, has. If youve got nothing to hide, many people say, you shouldnt worry about government surveillance. Despite the refrain that privacy is nothing to worry about for those who have nothing to hide solove 2007, localized individual harms from unwanted location disclosure rise with increased data. Ive got nothing to hide and other misunderstandings of privacy. This book part is brought to you for free and open access by the faculty scholarship at. Finally, solove reiterates the difficulty with the nothing to hide argument because most privacy problems lack dead bodies solove 768, meaning that people tend to focus on issues that viscerally and physically affect them while data mining, and privacy intrusion is. Final draft soloves essay nothingtohide argument has. Why we fail at data security and how to fix it with woodrow hartzog oxford university press under contract nothing to hide. This video has been made by cryptoparty berlin as an intro for cryptoparties. Pdf nothing to hide download full pdf book download. Nothing, to, hide collection opensource language english. Academic focus on the theme of having nothing to hide in relation to privacy management has only recently emerged e. The book examines the laws, government agencies and social concerns of the argument.
If youve got nothing to hide, youve got nothing to fear. Allen, university of pennsylvania law school daniel solove has had the patience and insight to lay privacy bare. May 15, 2011 when the government gathers or analyzes personal information, many people say theyre not worried. When the government gathers or analyzes personal information. Its not about having anything to hide, its about things not being anyone else. A student of privacy probably ought to understand various forms of privacy protection as well, such as safe harbor though it was not intended as a model, it is still instructive. Professor solove effectively convinces the audience that the nothingtohide argument doesnt successfully cover all of the problems that arise. Solove argues in this important book, these arguments and many others are flawed. Solove wrote when engaged directly, the nothing to hide argument can ensnare, for it forces the debate to focus on its narrow understanding of privacy. Why privacy matters even if you have nothing to hide wired. The false tradeoff between privacy and security scholarly. I have nothing to hide sounds good to lots of people. Solove gives us a richer concept of privacy, as a right to selfdetermination, dignity, due process, and a fair hearing in an increasingly automated. Why privacy matters even if you have nothing to hide.
1460 838 1616 880 900 951 891 457 1379 271 1451 1428 465 1078 1098 453 719 1500 1225 131 1323 589 1369 886 1275 996 1419 326 1059 12 390 316